Online education has transformed from a niche alternative into a dominant force reshaping higher education globally. As millions of students embrace digital classrooms and institutions expand their virtual offerings, one question increasingly dominates policy discussions and institutional planning: Is online course delivery financially sustainable? Understanding the cost dynamics behind this educational shift is essential for educators, administrators, and students navigating this evolving landscape.
Table of Contents
- The rapid expansion of online education
- Why cost-efficiency and ROI matter now
- The institutional perspective
- The student perspective
- Foundational theoretical frameworks
- D. Bruce Johnstone and cost-sharing theory
- Greville Rumble’s economics of distance education
- Alistair Inglis on online delivery costs
- Understanding the cost structure
- The global dimension
- Looking ahead
The rapid expansion of online education
The growth of online learning in recent years has been nothing short of remarkable. According to the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, total postsecondary enrollment increased by 3.2 percent in spring 2025, adding 562,000 students compared to the previous year. While this reflects broader enrollment recovery, online programs have been a significant driver of this growth.
Data from the National Center for Education Statistics reveals that 54% of college students took at least one online course in fall 2022, with about 26% taking classes exclusively online. This shift is not limited to undergraduate education. Master’s degree conferrals among programs available online exceeded conferrals in classroom-only programs by nearly 100,000 in 2023 , demonstrating how graduate education has embraced digital delivery.
The market implications are substantial. The global e-learning market is expected to reach $400 billion by 2026 , and 98% of higher education institutions now offer fully online degree programs, up from 77% in 2019. Private, nonprofit institutions have been particularly aggressive in expanding their online presence, with four-year degree-granting private nonprofits seeing the largest increase of 9.9% in online enrollments in 2024.
Why cost-efficiency and ROI matter now
Despite the enthusiasm surrounding online education’s growth, financial sustainability remains a pressing concern. Institutions worldwide are scrutinizing whether online course delivery actually saves money or simply shifts costs to different categories. For students and families, the question of return on investment has never been more urgent as education costs continue to rise.
The institutional perspective
From an institutional standpoint, distance education is often considered cost efficient because of its enormous potential to benefit from economies of scale. Dr. Barry Willis, a leading researcher in distance education economics, notes that because distance education courses are not restricted by classroom size, per student costs decrease as enrollment increases. However, achieving this potential is challenging, and maintaining efficiency becomes harder as competition grows.
The distinction between cost efficiency and cost effectiveness is crucial. Cost efficiency examines how expensive distance education is compared to other forms of instruction, while cost effectiveness asks whether the educational outcomes resulting from distance education are worth the cost. Institutions must address both dimensions to build sustainable online programs.
One significant finding from research on Illinois community colleges found that only 17% of the colleges studied achieved true cost-efficiency when offering online courses. This sobering statistic highlights the gap between the theoretical promise of online education and its practical implementation.
The student perspective
For students, the financial calculus is different but equally important. According to EducationData.org, tuition for a year of online college costs $6,765 less than a year of classes on campus, with the cost of an online degree representing 64.3% of the cost of a degree earned on campus. These savings primarily come from reduced room and board expenses, transportation costs, and often lower tuition rates.
Despite concerns about quality, 93% of surveyed students told BestColleges their online degree has or will have a positive return on investment in 2024. This represents a five percentage point increase since 2019, suggesting growing confidence in the value of online credentials. Additionally, 96% of online college graduates would recommend online learning to others.
Foundational theoretical frameworks
Understanding the cost dynamics of online education requires engaging with the theoretical frameworks developed by scholars who pioneered this field of study. Three researchers have been particularly influential in shaping how we analyze and understand the economics of distance and online learning.
D. Bruce Johnstone and cost-sharing theory
D. Bruce Johnstone, Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus at the State University of New York at Buffalo, developed the influential concept of cost-sharing in higher education. His work examines the universal phenomenon of cost-sharing in higher education-where financial responsibility shifts from governments and taxpayers to students and families.
Johnstone’s research demonstrates that growing costs for education far outpace public revenue streams that once supported it. This framework helps explain why online education has gained traction: as public funding shrinks, institutions seek more efficient delivery methods while students seek affordable alternatives. His comprehensive economic and policy analysis shows how economically diverse countries all face similar challenges in financing higher education.
Greville Rumble’s economics of distance education
Greville Rumble, a specialist in the costs and economics of open and distance learning, has provided foundational frameworks for understanding how distance education costs behave. His work at the UK Open University helped establish methodologies for costing distance education programs.
Rumble’s research addresses the assumption that drove early interest in distance education: people are interested in the costs and economics of distance education because they think it lowers costs. He notes that education was, and to a large extent still is, labour-intensive , and by the 1970s, few countries could afford the costs of providing education for growing populations. The hope was that technology would reduce unit costs of education-a hope that online delivery has partially fulfilled but with important caveats.
His book on the costs and economics of open and distance learning provides technical tools for analyzing cost behavior, examining everything from course design costs to media production, student support expenses, and comparative cost efficiency between distance and traditional education.
Alistair Inglis on online delivery costs
Alistair Inglis, a researcher at Victoria University in Melbourne, has focused specifically on comparing online delivery costs with alternative distance delivery methods. His work, including contributions to the Economics of Distance and Online Learning, addresses a fundamental question: Is online delivery less costly than print and is it meaningful to ask?
Inglis’s analysis examines various models of course delivery that claim reduced costs per student while also highlighting difficulties in comparing costs across different forms of distance education delivery. His research suggests that simple cost comparisons often miss important qualitative differences in educational outcomes and student experience.
Understanding the cost structure
The economics of online course delivery involves understanding the interplay between fixed and variable costs. Fixed costs-such as technology infrastructure, platform development, and initial course design-remain constant regardless of enrollment numbers. Variable costs-including instructional support, student services, and per-student administrative expenses-increase with each additional learner.
E-education has a distinct advantage because fixed costs can be distributed across a larger student base. As the number of students grows, the marginal cost of adding one more learner decreases, leading to greater cost efficiency. This scalability is what makes online education potentially more efficient than traditional classroom instruction.
However, creating quality online content requires substantial upfront investment. Course design and content creation typically involve instructional designers, subject matter experts, multimedia specialists, and technology professionals working together over extended periods. Once developed, though, this content can serve thousands of students without significant additional production expenses.
The global dimension
Cost-efficiency concerns in online education are not limited to any single country. From developing nations seeking to expand educational access affordably to developed countries facing budget constraints, the economics of online delivery has become a global conversation. There is, to a large degree, consensus regarding the economic benefits of distance education , though realizing these benefits requires careful planning and implementation.
The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated institutional adoption of online learning worldwide, forcing rapid digitization of education systems. While this demonstrated the feasibility of large-scale online delivery, it also exposed challenges in maintaining quality and managing costs effectively.
Looking ahead
As online education continues to mature, the focus is shifting from simple cost comparisons to more sophisticated analyses of cost-effectiveness and value creation. Institutions that succeed will be those that achieve genuine economies of scale while maintaining educational quality-a balance that requires strategic thinking about course design, technology investment, and student support.
For students, understanding these cost dynamics helps make informed decisions about educational investments. While online education often offers significant savings, the true value depends on program quality, career outcomes, and individual learning needs.
What do you think? As the economics of online education continue to evolve, how should institutions balance the pressure to reduce costs with the need to maintain educational quality? And for students considering online programs, what factors beyond tuition should influence decisions about educational investment?
References
- https://nscresearchcenter.org/current-term-enrollment-estimates/
- https://www.bestcolleges.com/research/online-learning-statistics/
- https://educationdata.org/cost-of-online-education-vs-traditional-education
- https://www.press.jhu.edu/books/title/9528/financing-higher-education-worldwide
- https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.15215/aupress/9781927356623.010/html?lang=en
- https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-981-97-9388-4_7
Leave a Reply